Quebec’s proposed legislation to combat hate speech is so flawed that it should be completely reworked and resubmitted for public consultation, medical according to the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA).

The Jewish community advocacy group told the public hearings that began last week that it is “perilous to use civil law to accomplish what is treated adequately by criminal law.”

CIJA’s chief criticism is that Bill 59 does not strike a fair balance between guaranteeing freedom of expression and protection against hate. It deplores the lack of a clear definition of what constitutes hate speech and of judicial safeguards for those accused of it.

“In its present form, no rx the bill risks creating an undesirable climate of self-censorship that is incompatible with fundamental rights and freedoms, and ” the CIJA written brief states.

Representatives of CIJA also appeared on Aug. 20 before the hearings being held at the National Assembly.

CIJA emphasized that the Jewish community, as one of the groups most frequently targeted by hate crimes in Canada, is deeply concerned with their prevention and the prosecution of those charged with them.

However, CIJA believes the answer is a more rigorous application of the existing hate speech provisions in the Criminal Code of Canada, under sections 318 to 320. It regrets that police seem reluctant to investigate and prosecutors to invoke those provisions. Criminal law also affords greater protection of free speech because of the burden of proof required, CIJA points out.

Bill 59, which was introduced in June by Justice Minister Stéphanie Vallée, is aimed at preventing and combating public hate speech and speech inciting violence against identifiable groups described in Section 10 of the Quebec Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms.

Individuals will also be covered by an amendment to the charter.

The bill gives the province’s Human Rights and Youth Rights Commission new powers, including the jurisdiction to investigate complaints about hate speech. It introduces the procedure by which citizens can make such complaints.

The commission can also seek a court order forcing hate speech to cease.

The Human Rights Tribunal also will have new responsibilities, including determining if a person has engaged in hate speech and imposing a monetary penalty.

Particularly troubling to CIJA is the tribunal’s power to enter the names of those found to have contravened the anti-hate prohibitions on a list to be kept at the commission and made available to the public on its website.

The justice minister is also given new powers. He or she may withhold all or part of public funding to educational institutions, public or private, from the preschool to college level, or even revoke their permit, in cases where the behaviour of any person who is on the hate-speech offenders list is presumed to pose a threat to students.

CIJA believes this is too vague and that the presumption of guilt violates basic rights.

Among other weaknesses, CIJA also notes that the bill does not stipulate whether public dissemination of hate speech includes that made via social media or the Internet. It also objects to the inclusion of “political convictions” as a category among identifiable groups that may be targeted.

It asks, for example, if denunciation of the Ku Klux Klan, could constitute hate speech. More generally, CIJA fears the stifling of genuine political debate.

It is concerned as well that those making complaints to the commission may remain anonymous, unless they consent to their identity being disclosed, which could encourage frivolous or malicious actions.

Overall, CIJA thinks the bill makes things too easy for plaintiffs. They do not have to appear before the tribunal or pay any legal fees and the standards for evidence are not spelled out. The defendant, on the other hand, must spend the time and money.

CIJA questions the severity of the sanctions: fines from $1,000 to $10,000 for a first offence, and the stigma and risk of reprisals posed by being publicly listed for a length of time at the tribunal’s discretion.

The normal rules of civil procedure should apply in the application of Bill 59 in order to assure a fair trial, CIJA says.

CIJA Quebec vice-president Luciano Del Negro said, during its presentation to the public hearings, government representatives on the committee “attempted to say that their legislation factors in our concerns. Their questions were not so much tough, as an attempt to reassure us.”

But CIJA is not convinced. “The intent of [Bill 59] is OK, but if the definition of hate speech is left so broad, action against it becomes arbitrary and discriminatory…

“The best antidote to hate speech is freedom of speech and education and a global strategy to deal with it.”

By Janice Arnold – The Canadian Jewish News

Seven decades after the end of WWII, malady research by a French Catholic priest has finally uncovered the devastating truth about the carnage inflicted by Nazis against the Jews during Ukraine’s “Holocaust of Bullets.”  reports that what started out as genealogical research for Father Patrick Desbois, turned out to be a fact finding mission during which, for the first time, local villagers in the Polish-border region of Rava Ruska opened up about the atrocities they witnessed towards Jews at the hands of the Nazis.

The accounts of torture, rape, dehumanization, and mass murder included in Father Debois’ research spell some of the most gruesome accounts documented to date, while dispelling many ‘official’ accounts of the events documented in Ukranian history.

According to his research, some 2,000 mass Jewish graves have to date been uncovered, but with a sense of urgency Debois insists that there may be as many as 6,000 yet to be unearthed.

“The challenge is to collect the maximum amount of evidence about the killing of the Jews in these countries and find out about the mass graves,” Debois said.  “Tomorrow the witnesses will disappear and the deniers will overreact, saying that the Jews falsified the story.”


Yishai Shlissel was indicted today in a Jerusalem court for his terror attack on the Jerusalem Gay Pride Parade, shop Israeli media reported.

Shlissel (sometimes spelled “Schlissel”) murdered 16-year-old Shira Banki at the parade and tried to murder six other marchers during the July 30 parade. He was restrained and arrested July 30 while he was still trying to stab more marchers.

The 39-year-old Schlissel was charged with one count of premeditated murder, check six counts of attempted murder, and with causing injuries under aggravated circumstances.

Shlissel’s remand was also extended until tomorrow, when another hearing will be held on his detention.

At the reading of the indictment, Shlissel reportedly told the court that “the [Gay] Pride Parade must be canceled to elevate Shira Banki’s soul. If you care for her wellbeing, you must cease this blasphemy against God. The [Gay Pride Parades] bring harsh decrees on Israel.…Whenever there is a Gay Pride Parade, stop the blasphemy against God. Stop the madness and all the people of Israel should repent.”

In 2005, Shlissel also staged a terror attack on the Jerusalem Gay Pride Parade, stabbing four people. He served ten years in prison and was released only three weeks before this year’s parade.

Police, however, failed to watch Shlissel or prepare for the possibility he would attack this year’s parade – even though Shlissel made public statements after his release in the haredi media and in pamphlets he distributed warning that the parade must be stopped and calling on all Jews to rise up and sacrifice themselves to protect the name of God from the abomination of the parade by preventing it from being held.

Despite all this, police claim intelligence information they received did not indicate Shlissel might attack this year’s parade, so they failed to closely monitor him.

But police also appear to have failed to follow their own security plan for the parade, and their apparent negligence in this regard also contributed to Banki’s murder and to the stabbings of the other victims.

Several mid-level police officials are expected to be reassigned over the failures – a response to the widespread failures many in the LGBT community feel is inadequate, especially in light of Banki’s murder.

By Shmarya Rosenberg –

Feathers flew in Manhattan court Tuesday as a group of residents demanded that a judge stop the “unsanitary’’ Jewish religious ritual of slaughtering chickens on the sidewalk during Yom Kippur.

“This is an epidemic waiting to happen. We just had this Legionnaire’s break out in The Bronx where 12 people died, rx ” said Nora Marino, prescription the lawyer for the Alliance to End Chickens as Kaporos, troche whose members carried photos of bloodied dead chickens into the courtroom.

The practice violates 15 different laws included in city and state health and agriculture regulations, Marino said.

Some Jewish people believe that the September ritual Kaporos absolves one’s sins with the sacrifice of a chicken.

Rabbi Shea Hecht, a human rights commissioner under former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, was in court to call the lawsuit “an attack on our religious freedom.”

But Marino’s 19 clients — from the Borough Park and Crown Heights neighborhoods in Brooklyn where the ritual takes place — say the resulting “stench, litter, blood, feces and feathers” pollute city streets.

“I am an elderly woman, and this scene horrifies me each year,” said 93-year-old Borough Park resident Frances Emeric.

“I saw live chickens with dead chickens and chickens screaming while the people participating in the ritual were holding the birds by their wings,” Emeric said, describing last year’s Kaporos.

David Jaroslawicz, who represents Hecht, derided the protesting residents as a bunch of “vegetarians” and “vegans” who whipped up “make-believe hysteria where it doesn’t exist.”

He noted that during the past 40 years that the ritual has taken place, not one person has fallen ill from the slaughtered chickens.

Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Debra James said she’ll rule Sept. 10, about a week before the three-day slaughter festivities start.

By The New York Post

Following a horrific attack that sent a Chassidic man to the hospital after being beaten, purchase choked and doused with gasoline, community leaders are notifying the community that the attack did not appear to be racially motivated and the police are treating it as criminal in nature.

““Last night, a member of Montreal’s Chassidic Jewish community was severely beaten in the Cote des Neiges district; as of Friday morning, the attacker was still at large,” wrote the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA). “Montreal police are treating the incident with the utmost seriousness, and are investigating all possible motives for the attack.  However, we stress that at this time there is nothing to suggest that this was a hate crime, and no conclusions should be drawn until the police investigation is complete. CIJA’s Director of Community Security, Adam Cohen, is in close communication with senior police officials. CIJA will advise the community of any significant developments.”

Rabbi Reuven Poupko told CBC News that he was informed by police that the attack did not appear to be a hate crime, yet it was “criminal in nature.”

Constable Andre Leclerc told CTV News that there is nothing yet that indicates that the victim was attacked because of his religion. “We did not conclude, we did not confirm the reason of this crime, if it’s a hate crime or not,” he said. “We’re going to wait for the work done by the investigators.”

The suspect is described as a man in his twenties wearing light coloured clothing. After beating, choking (for over a minute) and dousing the victim with gasoline, he was chased off and ran west along Van Horne. Police investigators searched the surrounding area for the bottle from which the gasoline had been poured, used sniffer dogs to try and locate the attacker, but were unsuccessful.

Constable Leclerc said that the victim was conscious when police arrived but his condition worsened in the hospital and he was sedated. Chaverim Shomrim reported that the victim was taken off the respirator Friday morning and has no broken bones. Nonetheless, they urged the community to continue praying and saying Tehillim (Psalms) for Shlomo Zalmen Ben Sheva.

By Zvi Hershcovich –

As more information about the beating and choking of a Chassidic man is released, an anonymous donor has come forward offering $10,000 to anyone who can provide information that will lead to the arrest of a suspect.

A community member who asked to remain anonymous is offering $10,000 for any information leading to the arrest of the man who beat, choked and doused a liquid witnesses told smelled like gasoline on a Chassidic man who exited the Bank of Montreal at the corner of McEachran and Van Horne Thursday evening.

In an interview with the Montreal Gazette, a witness said that he had been inside the bank with two friends just before the attack. As they left, they noticed a “muscular 25-year-old man” sitting on a bench outside the bank’s front door, holding a plastic bottle of Naya water.

The witness, a longtime local who runs a restaurant, had never seen the man in the neighbourhood before and had an “unsettling” feeling about him. “When you see a new face, you notice it,” he told the Gazette. “There was something strange about his calmness, about how he was sitting there.”

As the witness and his friends chatted at the street corner, they heard a loud crack from behind them. They turned and saw the man pouring his bottle of “water” over the victim.

The witness’ friends started chasing the attacker, but police advised them over the phone to stop for their own safety and the attacker got away.

The witness stayed with the victim who was bleeding from his head, moving around but not responding to questions. “We were all panicking,” said the witness. “But I told him ‘don’t move. You’ve been attacked. Help is on the way.’”

The witness also suggested that the liquid was gasoline, telling the Gazette that there was no car nearby that would have given off the smell.

According to the witness, the suspect and the victim had never spoken, and he hadn’t heard any insults or slurs.

Montreal police took samples of the liquid that they will test in a lab to determine what it was. While they haven’t confirmed yet if the liquid was gasoline, they told Global News that it wasn’t corrosive.

Canine units were sent to try and locate the water bottle and the suspect. Neither were ultimately found.

They also confirmed that nothing had been stolen from the victim, even though he had car keys, a wallet and his phone on him at the time. As to whether the bank’s security footage captured the scene, police did not confirm.

The suspect is described as a Caucasian male in his 20s with short brown hair who was wearing a pale blue shirt and black pants.

Community leaders have stressed that there is nothing to suggest that the attack was anti-Semitic in nature. Many Synagogues in the Outremont area held public gatherings to pray for the victim.

The victim, who was sedated upon arrival to the hospital after suffering a seizure, has seen a vast improvement in his health and was released on Monday afternoon. Miraculously, even though he had been reportedly choked for over a minute, he had no broken bones. However, he could not recall the assault although he did remember his rescuers.

While his health has improved, people can continue saying Tehillim (Psalms) for Shlomo Zalmen Ben Sheva, and the family has requested that anyone who would like to visit the victim should please contact his father to coordinate a time that would be appropriate.

People who have more information about the attack are asked to call the police (911). All information received will remain confidential and anonymous. A $10,000 reward is waiting for anyone who can provide the police with information leading to the arrest of the suspect.

By Zvi Hershcovich –

The Government has said it will not arrest Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for “war crimes” in Gaza when he visits London next month – despite 82, for sale 000 petitioners asking authorities to do so.

In its written response, purchase a Foreign and Commonwealth Office statement read: “Under UK and international law, pills visiting head of government, such as Prime Minister Netanyahu, have immunity from legal process, and cannot be arrested or detained.”

The petition originated last month and would trigger a parliamentary debate if it reaches 100,000 signatures, with organisers saying Netanyahu should be held responsible for the “massacre” of over 2,000 people in Gaza last year.

Activist Damian Moran said: “It is a clear message to him that there’s a massive amount of people who don’t want him here.”

Sir Eric Pickles, the former minister and current chairman of Conservative Friends of Israel, said the petition was “absurd” and would have “no impact” on relations between the two states. The Israeli embassy described it as a “meaningless publicity stunt”.


The Jewish Eldercare Centre celebrated its birthday along with those of some of its clients on July 29. Eleven of them are between 100 and 106 years young.

Claire Fern was born in New York on Feb. 28, nurse 1908 and began working on Wall St. in the late 1920s just before the crash of the stock market. When asked about the secret to her longevity, prescription she said “It’s not a secret. It is all in the hands of God.”

by The Montreal Gazette

The administration of the mikvah (ritual bath) used by the chevrah kadisha (burial society) in the hasidic enclave of Kiryas Tosh in Canada as decided not to change the water in the mikvah, treatment which was used for the immersion of the body of the elderly Rebbe of Tosh Rabbi Meshulam Feivish Lowy after he passed away August 11 at age 94.

Instead, healing Tosh intends to leave the water unchanged and charge hasidim – some of whom will be traveling from the US and other countries to Tosh for the High Holidays – $40 a pop to immerse in it before or during the holidays, cialis Behadrei Haredi reported – an almost certain violation of health codes and something that is appears not to be a known Jewish custom.


A Chassidic man in his 20s is in critical condition and on a respirator after being viciously attacked outside an Outremont bank.

According to witnesses, seek the assailant was sitting on a bench outside of the bank located on the corner of Van Horne and McEachran at around 7:15pm on Thursday night.

When the man came out of the bank, help the assailant attacked, choking, beating and then pouring an known liquid over him. The attacker then fled.

Police say that nothing seems to have been taken from the victim during the attack.

“The victim was conscious at the arrival of police, but got worse at the hospital” said police spokesman Andrè Leclerc, “He is now unconscious and under sedation.”

People close to the victim told Yeshiva World News that he is suffering from a spinal fracture and bleeding to the brain.

Late Thursday evening the police brought in their K-9 unit to try and locate the attacker. They were unsuccessful.

The suspect is described as a white male in his 20s, with short brown hair. Police say he was wearing a light blue shirt and black shorts.

Montreal Jewish News